Why Truck Crashes Differ: Mass, Braking, Articulation

Why a loaded tractor-trailer moves unlike a car. Speed and stopping, brake lag and heat, center of gravity, rearward amplification and jackknife.

Tanker truck traveling on a divided highway.
Tanker truck traveling on a divided highway. Photograph: Carlos ZGZ. CC0 via commons.wikimedia.org. Resized and converted to WebP; display may crop.

A loaded tractor-trailer is heavy, tall and hinged in the middle, and each of those facts changes how it moves. Weight sets how much energy the brakes have to turn into heat. Height sets how easily it tips. The hinge at the fifth wheel means the vehicle can fold, swing or whip in ways a one-piece car cannot. This piece follows those three properties through the commercial driver training material that teaches drivers to manage them.

Speed and stopping

Commercial driver training uses a square law to show how fast stopping demands grow. The New Jersey CDL manual says that doubling speed from 20 to 40 mph makes the impact four times greater and the braking distance four times longer, and that tripling it to 60 mph makes both nine times greater. At 80 mph, it says, they are 16 times what they are at 20 mph. Those figures illustrate the relationship. They are not a crash reconstruction, which would also depend on how the vehicles deform.

Stopping distance in that manual is a sum: perception distance, reaction distance and braking distance. A truck with air brakes adds a fourth term, brake lag. The manual explains that hydraulic brakes on cars and light and medium trucks work instantly, while air brakes need a little time, one half second or more, for air to flow through the lines to the brakes. Truck stopping distance works through each term, and commercial truck braking systems covers the hardware.

Mass and heat

The heavier the vehicle, the manual says, the more work the brakes must do to stop it and the more heat they absorb. Heat is the limit on long downgrades. Brake fade comes from excessive heat changing the lining chemically and expanding the drums, so the shoes travel farther and press with less force. Pushed far enough, the brakes can no longer slow or stop the vehicle, which is why drivers are taught to use engine braking as the main way to hold speed on a long grade and the service brakes as a supplement.

Weight does not mean a heavier truck always stops farther. The brakes, tires, springs and shock absorbers on heavy vehicles are designed to work best fully loaded, according to the manual, and empty trucks need more distance to stop because an empty vehicle has less traction. Large combinations take longer to stop empty than fully loaded, because very stiff springs and strong brakes on a light load give poor traction and lock the wheels easily. The manual also warns about bobtail tractors running without a semitrailer: tests have shown they can be very hard to stop smoothly, and they take longer to stop than a tractor-semitrailer loaded to maximum gross weight.

Height and rollover

Cargo piled higher moves the center of gravity up, and the manual says the truck becomes easier to turn over. Its two remedies are keeping cargo as close to the ground as possible and driving slowly around turns, and it says keeping cargo low matters even more in a combination than in a straight truck. A load sitting to one side makes the trailer lean and makes a rollover more likely, so the load should be centered and spread out. Rollovers happen when a driver turns too fast, including on ramps.

The load is part of the vehicle's mass and balance, which is why federal cargo securement rules at 49 CFR 393.100 require cargo to be contained, immobilized or secured so that it cannot shift enough to affect the vehicle's stability or maneuverability.

The hinge: rearward amplification

A combination responds to steering in stages. The manual calls this the crack-the-whip effect and says a quick lane change can turn the trailer over, even when the tractor stays upright. The cause is rearward amplification. The manual's chart, drawn from a 1983 University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute study, compares eight combination types. A rearward amplification of 2.0 means the rear trailer is twice as likely to turn over as the tractor, and triples show 3.5, so the last trailer of a triple can be rolled 3.5 times as easily as a five-axle tractor.

The driving advice follows from the physics: steer gently and smoothly, look far enough ahead to avoid a sudden lane change, and avoid quick lane changes when fully loaded.

The hinge: jackknife

A jointed vehicle can fold when wheels lock. If a trailer's wheels lock, the manual says, the trailer tends to swing around, which it calls a trailer jackknife, and this is more likely when the trailer is empty or lightly loaded. The earliest sign is in the mirrors. Once the trailer swings out of its lane, a jackknife is very hard to prevent. The fix is to release the brakes so the trailer wheels regain grip and the trailer follows the tractor again, and not to use the trailer hand brake, since trailer braking caused the skid.

When the tractor's drive wheels lock instead, locked wheels have less traction than rolling wheels, so they slide sideways and the trailer can push the tractor sideways into a sudden jackknife. Antilock brakes help. The manual says ABS should prevent brake-induced skids and jackknifes, but not those caused by spinning the drive wheels or going too fast in a turn, and it will not necessarily shorten stopping distance.

The hinge: off-tracking

In a turn, the rear wheels follow a different path, inside the path of the front wheels. The manual calls this off-tracking, or cheating, and says longer vehicles off-track more. The tractor's rear wheels off-track some, the trailer's rear wheels more, and with more than one trailer the last trailer's rear wheels off-track the most. Drivers are taught to swing the front end wide enough that the rear clears the curb, while keeping the rear close to the curb so other drivers cannot pass on the right. Off-tracking is one reason the space beside a turning truck is dangerous, a subject covered in commercial truck blind spots.

What this page does not cover

This page explains vehicle behavior. It does not rank crash causes or quote crash counts. The figures above come from driver training material that teaches drivers how to handle a heavy combination, and the semi truck weight limits page covers how much a combination may legally weigh.

Sources

More from road safety